The Only Reason We Married Was For Health Insurance

Photo: Mila Supinskaya Glashchenko / Shutterstock
We Married For Health Insurance
Partner
Love

By Nona Willis Aronowitz

I'd never been one of those girls who'd dreamt about her perfect wedding. The virgin-white dress, the exorbitant costs, the fuss over a big, shiny rock — none of it ever appealed to me.

I wanted to find a lifelong partner, and a family sounded nice, too. But honestly? I never cared much about that piece of paper.

So why did I just marry my boyfriend after pondering it for a mere two hours? One (evidently all-too-common) reason: we married for health insurance.

My now-husband is a bartender and a student whose school's insurance is exorbitant. The man hadn't gone to the doctor in years, living in fear of a major accident or illness.

We had lived together for about eight months when I got a job as a reporter for a newspaper with a kick-ass medical plan. According to my job, a domestic partnership affidavit was standing in the way of my partner having awesome coverage and escaping $8,000 worth of retroactive hospital bills.

It was a no-brainer. Onto domestic partnership!

RELATED: Is The Health Care System Racist? 5 Ways Black People Are Affected By Medical Racism

Problem is, the state of Illinois doesn't let you claim domestic partnership as a legally binding. Domestic partnerships are seen as informal and as a long-term committed relationship than something that legally binds two people together, like marriage or a civil union.

("If they could, no one would get married!" the City Hall employee informed me smugly as if 1. that fact was actually true, and 2. rampant domestic partnerships would mean the end of the world). Apparently, you can marry if you're queer with legal marriages, but you can't opt-out of the "system" if you're straight.

It started to seem so ridiculously arbitrary and unfair! Did I really have to choose between leaving my honey vulnerable to unthinkable medical costs and a measly certificate? 

The choice was clear. We went ahead and got married.

The weird thing wasn't the actual City Hall wedding (it was actually sort of fun!), it was watching people react to the news. Some were angry — "How could you have gotten married without me there?" my best friend implored, crushed. Others were confused — "Really, Nona? I thought you weren't into that sorta stuff."

RELATED: There’s No Way In Hell I’d Have A Child If I Had No Health Insurance

But the most common reaction was voyeuristic elation — from everyone, even my long-lost elementary school friends on Facebook. It was like I had become part of some coveted club, or even a higher-class citizen.

I understood more than ever why gay marriage was such a big deal. I also started to get why people become so wrapped up in weddings. It's your moment. All eyes are on you. Suddenly, everybody loves you!

Mine is a situation that's left me contemplating my principles. By getting insurance-married on the fly, did I "give in" or did I give tradition the finger?

Maybe a little bit of both? I have nothing against weddings — nothing's better than a celebration of love — and if my husband and I decide to get married "for real," I'm sure we'll have an epic one. But the government certificate thing has always made me indignant, especially now when health insurance is a necessity.

Why should someone be able to have health insurance easier because they happen to have that legally binding document? Or, for that matter, if they believe in the institution of marriage as the only way to support it?

Either way, our shotgun wedding was just as much of a gesture of love as anything else. People get married for a lot worse reasons than ensuring their loved one's health, safety, and peace of mind.

And, at the very least, now I know my vow of "in sickness and in health" is backed up by a PPO insurance plan.

RELATED: 4 Things You Need To Know About Medical Debt (So It Doesn't Bury You)

Nona Willis Aronowitz writes for Teen Vogue, The New York Times, Vice, and The Cut. Visit her website for more.

Sign Up for the YourTango Newsletter

Let's make this a regular thing!

​Editor's Note: This article was originally posted in December 2009 and was updated with the latest information.

Author
Partner