Vegan & Carnivore: A Sweet Story Of Love And Compromise

Photo: Getty Images 
woman holding fruit
Contributor
Love

When we spew off our must-haves for the perfect mate—a sense of humor, steady job, an encyclopedic knowledge of Breaking Badrarely do we talk about food. When was the last time one of your friends said she's looking for a guy who's tall, dark, handsome, and knows five tasty ways to prepare Swiss chard?

But when it comes to eating habits and relationships, what ends up on the dinner table can be just as important as what goes down in the bedroom. In fact, as we pointed out in our story 7 Reasons to Date a Vegetarian, a third of omnivorous singles wouldn't even consider dating a non-meat eater. Pssh!

So, in a world dominated by carnivores, what's a bacon-free bachelor or bachelorette to do?

Well, for the 7.3 million vegetarians in the US (according to the Vegetarian Times) there are a number of veggie-only dating sites. Among them are VeggieDate.org, VeggieFishing.com, VegetarianDating.com, and EthicalSingles.com. That said, how boring the dating pool would be if we all stayed in our own grocery aisles?

To figure out how two people on opposite sides of the dietary spectrum could ever come together, we chatted with New Yorker Kristin Jackson.

While she's vegan, her boyfriend Jake is a full-fledged BBQ-lovin', steak-makin', meat-eating man. Kristin keeps a blog, My Fit Decision, where she chronicles her healthy lifestyle, including the his-and-hers meals she creates.

Here's what Kristin told us about how these two lovebirds make it work. To those 30 percent who don't think omni/veggie love is possible, take note!

Dropping the 'V Bomb'

That's 'V' as in vegetarian or vegan. For Kristin, who has been meat-free in some form since she was 13, there was no pre-vegan era in her relationship with Jake, who she started dating two years ago. So how did she first introduce her diet?

"I tested the water on the first date," she says. "He asked where I wanted to go for dinner so I picked a vegan place. He was cool with it." Before dating Jake, Kristin had been on a couple of dates with guys who weren’t as keen on her restaurant selection, and she knew right away that they weren't matches.

"It's a good sign if a guy is open to it right off the bat. If he's not open to trying a meat-free meal on the first date when he's trying hard to impress you, then he's really not going to be up for it on the tenth date," she says.

Table for Two

When eating out, Kristin admits that she sometimes annoys Jake with her lengthy requests. "I'll pick something and tell the waiter to hold the chicken and the cheese and the egg, and Jake is like, "I don’t know her!’" she says.

But for the most part, any hard feelings come from a place of concern. Kristin remembers one night out when she was stuck eating a plate of pickled cabbage for dinner because there weren't many meatless options.

"When that happens, Jake doesn't get angry at me for not eating meat," she says. "Rather, he feels upset that I have to just sit there and watch him eat a plate full of food." Fortunately, though, experiences like that are few and far between because the couple keeps an eye on local menus, and they know the spots that suit them both.

They've zeroed in on places like Mable's Smokehouse in Brooklyn, which serves both beef brisket and vegetarian sloppy Joes.

The Grocery Cart: The Window to the Soul

While other couples might take a trip down the frozen food aisle for granted, for Kristin and Jake it's a weekly bonding experience. "You can learn a lot about people when you watch what they put in their grocery carts," says Kristin.

While she's more comfortable in the produce section than at the deli counter, the two choose to focus on what they have in common when they shop, like an interest in eating healthy.

"Even though I don't eat meat, I'll still help Jake pick out chicken and come up with a healthy way to prepare it," she says. Their common interest in eating well is more the focus than the fact that she prefers tempeh to a T-bone.

RELATED: 44 Foods You Didn't Know Were Vegan

The Couple That Dines Together, Does Fine Together

When Kristin and Jake eat together at home, whether at her place or his, they make a point to eat similar dishes, even though hers are meat-free. On her blog, Kristin details these dinners with "His Plate/Her Plate" posts.

One week it's sweet potatoes for her, and mango jalapeno sausage for him, both served over brown rice and beans.  Another week it's a Caribbean theme, and though she's made jerk chicken for him and jerk cauliflower for herself, their meals look surprisingly similar.

Making visually cohesive meals is important to the pair. 

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Hey You! Want more of YourTango's best articles, seriously addictive horoscopes and top expert advice? Sign up to get our free daily newsletter!

"Eating is about connecting," Kristin says. "Growing up, my family always ate dinner together and we always ate the same food. It's important that Jake and I do that, too. It unifies us. Plus, it's a good way to show him that even though I'm vegan, I can still eat similar things."

RELATED: 9 Expert Tips For Making Quick, Healthy Meals In Minutes

Vegan, Don't Preach

Even though Kristin is vegan because of environmental and ethical reasons, she doesn't pressure Jake to live the same way. "I would love it if he became vegetarian, but if I push him, that could be the end of us.

I care about him too much to allow that to ruin our relationship. It's not worth it to me," she says. "

The most important thing in a relationship like ours is to be open-minded. It's a two-way street. If I want him to respect what I eat, then I have to respect what he eats. It's okay to educate, but the moment you start to make people feel bad, that’s the moment you lose them."

RELATED: The 3 Best Organic Vegan Recipes That Are High-Protein And Healthy

But while Kristin doesn’t try to convert Jake, she does encourage him to buy free-range meat. She also hopes to influence his veggie intake. "My dream is to get him to eat kale and spinach," she says. "I just want him to appreciate how good kale is."

Amelia Mularz is an LA-based writer and freelance journalist. She's contributed pieces to Harper’s Bazaar, Travel + Leisure, Refinery29, Los Angeles Magazine, The Knot, Martha Stewart Weddings, Fathom, and others. Visit her website for more of her work.