Men Who Want Another Chance But Won’t Treat You Any Better Usually Do 4 Predictable Things

Last updated on Sep 16, 2026

Calm, direct expression on a city street, the same even tone people use when asking for another chance. Alexey Gorkiy | Shutterstock
Advertisement

It hurts. I know it hurts. There is nothing more painful than having the person you love break your heart. Like literally. You can feel it shatter into a thousand pieces.

Yes, relationships are hard work, and they rarely work the same way the second time around. You could be an exception to the rule, and he could be, too. But let’s not get lost in the moment and forget the signs of why you should just keep walking, even if it kills you, too.

Advertisement

Men who want another chance but won’t treat you any better will probably do these things:

1. They're interested in you, but remorseful

man interested in woman but unremorseful PeopleImages | Shutterstock

If the man you love so dearly isn't showing remorse or taking responsibility for the actions that caused the breakup, why are you letting him back in? Relationships are a two-way street. No one is perfect; we get it. But each person needs to be accountable to the other and for their actions.

Advertisement

Maybe he wasn’t toxic. Maybe your baggage broke things apart. However, it takes two to tango, and you need to look at why he's contacting you again. Does he want to make it work, like really make it work? Is he truly sorry for what he has done? Or is this just his way of keeping you on tenterhooks because he doesn’t want anyone else to have you?

His attitude throughout the break-up will give you a good indication of how he feels, so don’t forget to look at the whole process and not just the part where the prince comes to rescue you.

RELATED: 12 Habits That Signal A Man Will Break Your Heart With Zero Remorse

2. He's hanging around but not actively trying to win you back

If a man messed up and lost you, then he should be doing everything in his power to win you back. Let’s not sugarcoat this, ladies: if a man wants to be with you, he will do anything to make that happen.

Advertisement

The problem is that as soon as we get a little bit from them, we tend to throw out all that hard work of healing and being strong, all for the little they are offering in return. We focus on our present pain instead of the past cause of the pain. Right now, if he is not putting in that extra effort to pursue you and woo you again, then you shouldn’t be entertaining the thought of giving him a second chance.

3. He wants you to forget what he did — not just forgive

man wanting woman to forget mistakes not just be forgiven fizkes | Shutterstock

When you are in a world of pain, it is easy to think a moment of hope will make everything the way it should be. If your relationship fell apart because your partner cheated, betrayed, or hurt you in a significant way, then that is something you shouldn’t forget so readily.

Advertisement

Yes, forgiveness is important, more so for your sake than theirs, but it shouldn’t serve as a way to erase the cold, hard truth about their character and what they did. Don’t lose perspective on why you split just because you haven’t been able to move on.

RELATED: How To Forgive Someone When You Know You Will Never Be Able To Forget What They Did

4. He's not interested in giving you a sense of peace or security

The biggest sign your relationship is healthy and right is peace. This isn’t about him just fulfilling a temporary need or emotion, but rather having a constant sense of deep peace about your partnership.

Here’s the thing: relationships aren’t meant to be full of turmoil or anxiety. There will be seasons of hardship, but the growth and effort should always be equal and mutual. Your heart and mind should be aligned. It isn’t meant to be a constant battle in your head.

Advertisement

If you have broken up, my guess is there was some lack of peace in the first place. Because people don’t break up to get back together; they split because something is wrong, and change needs to happen. 

All you want to do is dissolve into a puddle of tears and preferably sleep until everything is better in 10 years’ time. Time becomes your enemy, and with each day, you slowly morph into a robot, void of any feeling but coping, just barely. It’s one extreme to the other. Total devastation, to just feeling completely emotionally empty. Like this big hole is left where they used to be.

It’s a grieving process that you start to get swallowed up in; even when you try to fight it, it slowly folds around your heart and mind. Then you get that text. That single text. That little message that says, “I miss you.”

The one that causes your blood to flow, your heart to race, and your mind to follow. Your senses come to life, and all you can think about is that maybe, just maybe, there’s a chance it could work again.

Advertisement

I’ve been there. Deep in the black hole, and then being drawn to the glimmer of hope that they dangle so tantalizingly in front of you. It’s a dangerous place to be because our emotions overwhelm our rational thinking.

We automatically forget the pain they caused or why it didn’t work out. In times of distress and longing, it’s easy to only remember the good times because that is what brings us comfort, and that is what we want to cling to.

But it didn’t work out. And there is a reason: a reason that caused you a lot of pain and is something you shouldn’t ignore. As much as you want to take him back, make sure you are doing it for the right reasons and from an emotionally intelligent place. Step outside your pain for a moment and ask yourself whether he truly adds to your life. Does he make you feel valued and loved, and does he have the mindset and qualities to give you the relationship you deserve? 

Advertisement

There are so many things we already settle for; love should not be one of them.

RELATED: 5 Reasons Your Breakup Is The Farthest Thing From A Failure

Renee Slansky is a relationship and dating coach and the founder of The Dating Directory, an online community for women focused on love, life, and relationships.

Loading...