Who Could Have Been Lindsay Lohan's Baby Daddy?

The Lindsay Lohan list was only the tip of the iceberg in showing just what a broken, hot mess the onetime Mean Girls star really is. The news of her miscarriage during the filming of her OWN series, Lindsay, was sadly met with the same combination of sympathy, skepticism and scorn that the rest of her troubles are — both by the general public and by those close to her.

An insider told Radar Online that he or she believes Lohan is actually making up the entire miscarriage story, about which she was pretty vague and almost nonchalant in comparison with her other dramas.

The source fumed, "Lindsay was never pregnant during filming the reality show for OWN, or in the months after. Lindsay knew she was being perceived as a total slacker, not showing up on time for photo shoots, call times and refusing to shoot. So this is what Lindsay does. She lies! Her family and friends had no clue about her 'pregnancy' and subsequent miscarriage. Lindsay is once again her own worst enemy."

Another Lohan source said, "Lindsay has continued to smoke through-out this entire series and has admitted to relapsing and drinking alcohol. Don't forget there have been multiple media reports that she fell off the wagon months ago. Quite simply, Lindsay never acted like someone who was pregnant. It's just sad that anything that comes out of her mouth is considered to be a lie."

In fairness to Lilo, it's possible that she never even knew she was pregnant, and that may be why she continued to smoke and drink while she was unknowingly with child. If a miscarriage occurs during early stages of pregnancy, it can often feel and seem like a really heavy period, with similar symptoms like bleeding and cramps. Often by the time women get medical attention, it's already over.

And let's be honest: Unprotected sex wouldn't be the worst decision Lohan has ever made, and if she did fall off the wagon, her decision-making ability would be even more impaired than normal. It may come off as a made up excuse, and it might be — but it's also pretty plausible.

With that said, two of Lohan's potential baby daddies were so blindsided by the miscarriage ordeal that they outright denied any possibility of paternity. A source close to one suitor, Matt Nordegren, swears that Lilo never even mentioned the pregnancy nor the miscarriage to him.

Another, 18-year-old Ralph Lauren model Morgan O'Connor, actually appeared briefly on Lindsay — and, well, on Lindsay. The handsome teen assures, though, that he's not the would-be dad. "Morgan always said Lindsay was crazy and he was afraid she would do something really stupid to get him in trouble," a source told Radar. "But he was serious when he said he wasn't the father."

Pro tip: Lohan can't get a guy in trouble if he doesn't hang out with her. Take some responsibility, kid.