5 *Shocking* Ways Your Marriage Is Making You Broke

Photo: WeHeartIt
Love, Self

Marriage is a wonderful way to seal your love, but could it be emptying your wallets, too?

Marriage is associated with all kinds of personal benefits, like more happiness and better health  but financial ones? Not so much. Especially if you're already living together and sharing household expenses.

While some couples who get hitched will get better treatment from the tax man or insurance providers, others could end up spending much more. See if you could be among couples who'll lose money just for making it official:

1. You're both breadwinners and you do better (or worse) than average.

The so-called "tax penalty" starts hitting childless couples jointly earning more than $171,000 per year, when both spouses are earning a decent income. As one spouse starts to significantly out-earn the other, the couple swings into tax bonus territory.

A similar pattern takes hold for couples collectively earning about $30,000 or less. Want to see how much more, or less, you'll pay in taxes if you tie the knot? Check out this Rorschach chart created by The New York Times.

If you have a child, you're much less likely to escape the long arms of the tax man. Only super-struggling couples with a kid( or those where one spouse earns little to no income) are likely to be better off tax-wise after getting married, compared to if they'd stayed single.

2. You get health insurance subsidies through the Affordable Care Act.

Let's say you're a 32-year-old living in San Francisco with your same-aged boyfriend or girlfriend. You're each scraping by on babysitting or bartending gigs, earning about $32,000 per year apiece, while you try to get your startup off the ground.

Through the California state exchange, you each get a subsidy of $129 per month to help you pay for health insurance (that's $3,096 over the course of the year, for the two of you).

Now, get married.

Your subsidies drop to exactly $0 because of the law's income limits on assistance. This can happen all over the country. Married couples earning more than 400 percent of the federal poverty level ($63,720 in 2015) are no longer eligible for health insurance subsidies.

Singles, however, can earn up to about $47,000 apiece (that's 400 percent of the poverty level for an individual in 2015), which is $94,000 collectively, and still get the help.


3. You share a health insurance plan  and use it.

Maybe you want to get married because you're pregnant and it makes sense for you to get a family plan, perhaps through one of your employers.

Watch out for a sneaky little clause that may not even be mentioned on the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage. It has to do with how the deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are applied to individuals versus the family as a whole.

An "embedded" deductible is what you want. If either of you gets sick or has a baby, once your bills hit the individual limits your insurer starts to pay. But if the plan uses an "aggregate" method, one person's bills can add up to the entire family's limit before insurance starts to pay.

Since family plan deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are often double what they are for individuals, the difference in what you'll have to pay out of pocket could be as high as $6,600 per year.

The aggregate method will be going the way of insurance companies' refusals to cover preexisting conditions (i.e. no longer allowed) as of 2016, thank goodness. Till then, beware.

4. You live off Social Security.

Are you a pair of retirees living "in sin"? That's so cute. What happens in this scenario is similar to the deal with the ACA subsidies. Two single people can earn much more than one married couple before they're subject to a financial hit. In this case, it's taxes on Social Security income.

Each single person can earn an income of up to $25,000 (not including one half of their Social Security benefits), for a total per unmarried couple of $50,000 before those benefits are taxed. But a married couple filing jointly can only earn up to $32,000 (not including one half of their Social Security) before the IRS wants some of it back.

Here's how this might work for two people, each receiving the average Social Security benefit of $1,294 per month. Let's say they each have an AGI plus non-taxable interest of exactly $17,235. Add in half the Social Security benefit of $7,764 and they're up to just under $25,000 apiece. Their Social Security benefits of $15,528 apiece won't be taxed.

That couple gets married, and now their income is well above the $32,000 level at which Social Security benefits start to be taxed. In fact, 85 percent of their SSI (or more than $26,397) will now be subject to federal income taxes.

Getting married might make sense for other reasons related to Social Security, especially if one of you has never earned much money, while the other has. Should the higher earning spouse die, the surviving spouse could get that person's benefit instead of his own.

5. You contribute to your Roth IRA.

Here, too, your newly joined income can hurt you. While single people can earn up to $116,000 apiece and each contribute the full amount to a Roth IRA ($5,500 or $6,500 for those over 50, in 2015); married couples begin to lose eligibility at $183,000. Marriage can also affect your ability to deduct traditional IRA contributions.

On the other hand, if one of you strongly out-earns the other, you may jointly qualify for more retirement savings options, like a spousal IRA for the lesser-earning one, based on your marital income.

Of course, it's not all bad news — there are a lot of ways getting married can save you money, like lower rates on auto, homeowners, and long-term care insurance.

Also, marriage allows for the automatic and federally untaxed transfer of your spouse's assets to you in the case of his or her death. Though if you're affected by too many of the scenarios mentioned above, there may not be as many assets left.



Rebecca Webber is a journalist who covers women's lifestyle and personal finance for ValuePenguin.com, including topics like family budgeting and healthcare. She regularly contributes articles to magazines and websites. 


Explore YourTango