Should You and Your Partner Conduct Year-End Performance Reviews


Should You and Your  Partner Conduct Year-End Performance Reviews

A recent article in the Wall Street Journal suggested that, just as work relationships hold year-end reviews for performance, there may be  benefits to such critiques in our personal lives as well. Although written in a humorous, tongue-in-cheek tone, points are made that are worth serious consideration.

As a counselor who has done work with managed care companies I have been required to undergo quarterly reviews by a supervisor. On one occasion, it was decided that peer reviews would  be conducted and should be more effective. The end result was an awful experience. Evaluation feedback was given anonymously, quickly making a group of people who previously worked well as a team suspicious of each other. Peer reviews were deemed as a bad idea and were never held again.

Can a performance review from your significant other—also a peer—really be beneficial? To be evaluated by anyone automatically puts that person in a superior or dominant position; exactly the opposite of an equal loving relationship.

Which categories should be covered? Certainly being on the same page with your partner regarding money attitudes, personal habits, raising the kids, and dealing with your extended family are important areas to include. Another issue to consider is specific criteria. Which aspects of your relationship should you include? Strengths and weaknesses should be discussed, as well as appreciation for what’s already working.

Job reviews, ideally, result in improved performance, but other elements must be in place for this to happen. The best outcomes are the result of honest, clear, positive and negative feedback. There must also be a level of trust and respect between both parties. Incentive to change, in the form of some type of reward, is important as well. With regard to employment, that reward usually means a pay raise, more vacation time, or other tangible financial benefits. Rewarding good performance within a personal relationship is important too. How would you reward your partner, or yourself? As a counselor, I would recommend a reward that benefits both partners in a relationship as opposed to separate “prizes.” Or should it be diamonds, sexual favors, or no housework. The reward needs to motivate each partner to work hard  in order to maintain consistent energy for the changes needed.

The most significant aspect of a relationship performance review, however, boils down to your personal connection as a couple. How well you communicate will be the biggest determining factor in whether a performance review will benefit your relationship or not.
For couples who are struggling and not feeling connected, a performance review would likely have a negative effect and cause serious damage to an already fragile relationship. You must both feel your relationship is strong enough to withstand this kind of direct feedback.

Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Stuart Fensterheim

Marriage and Family Therapist

Stuart Fensterheim LCSW

Signup to get my Quarterly Newsletter, and you’ll receive relationship tips, articles and suggestions that can help you today!

Location: Scottsdale, AZ
Credentials: LCSW
Other Articles/News by Stuart Fensterheim:

Don't Stop Believing...In Each Other


Don't Stop Believing In Relationships Every couple needs to find opportunities to nurture their relationship. Without this, your relationship becomes stale and isolating. Last evening, my wife and I went to Kieland commons to see a free concert on the mall. We clearly were not alone; it was jam packed with couples, singles, families, dogs and others who ... Read more

The Secret 5 Steps To Creating A Love That Lasts Forever


Developing the secure, fulfilling bond you deserve with your partner is hard work, but it is not impossible. Below are five characteristics of every strong bond and what you can do to help create a deep, loving connection. 1. You And Your Partner Must Truly Become Best Friends But what is a best friend? A best friend is likely someone you have known for a ... Read more

Relationships & Marriage: How To Make Love Last Forever


A deep, loving relationship once was thought to be a dream. However, I assure you that we now have enough information about love to help any couple create a positive and love-filled relationship that has both of you feeling special and important. Understanding what it takes to establish a loving relationship with your partner can make you feel stronger ... Read more

See More


Sign up for our daily email and get the stories everyone is talking about.

Ask The Experts

Have a dating or relationship question?
Visit Ask YourTango and let our experts and community answer.