Is Your Valentine's Gift The Gift That Keeps On Giving?


Is Your Valentine's Gift The Gift That Keeps On Giving?
If you are getting a divorce, your gift may not be entirely yours anymore.

Valentine's Day can be an awesome day of love and for many, a day to receive a big gift from your loved one. But get this—that gift that you love so dearly may cause you trouble when you are in the process of divorce. Consider this scenario:

Before you were married, your then boyfriend-turned-husband gave you that heart-shaped diamond necklace you've always wanted. You were ecstatic because you knew that the diamond necklace cost thousands of dollars, and he must really love you. Fast forward to years later and unfortunately you are in the process of divorce. Your husband might be mad at you and want his diamond necklace back. In fact, he wants half of the value of your necklace split as a marital asset. Is that necklace yours or does it belong to the marriage?

Actually, that necklace is all yours, because it was given to you before the marriage. Pretty interesting, right? Divorce Attorney and Huffington Post blogger Christian Denmon (Denmon and Denmon) offers some insightful information about gifts we receive from our loved one:

“A gift to your fiancé before marriage is a true gift in the traditional sense. Ownership has been passed to a sole individual and if they can prove that they are the primary user of this gift—such as a photo of said individual wearing jewelry often—the gift cannot be taken back. When one spouse gifts an item to another spouse before marriage the item becomes separate property and is not considered marital property, even if the parties subsequently marry and spend many years together as Husband and Wife."

However, let's say you loved that diamond necklace so much, that you decided to add more diamonds to it. Or perhaps you took out the smaller diamonds and replaced them with bigger bling. Does that necklace still belong to you? Nope—it's now considered marital property and the value of the necklace is now subject to a 50/50 split. Or how many of you got that "cute" diamond engagement ring when you were 23 years old, but upgraded by adding more or larger diamonds to it during your marriage? Yeah, that now belongs to him too.

Now consider this scenario:
You and your husband have split and he tries to woo you back with that expensive watch you've always wanted. You accept it, yet you still break up and now he wants his watch back—who does it belong to? Christian Denmon says it's all yours. "Jealousy or hurt emotions can trigger someone to give a gift," Denmon says, "but if the gift is given once you have separated, then it is not considered a marital asset."

Why didn't my divorce attorney tell me this? If you are currently undergoing a divorce, make sure you ask your attorney about gifts and/or upgrades to gifts you have received. Gift-giving can be quite tricky and cause headache or heartache, depending on where you are in your break-up.

Do you have legal questions about your gifts? Comment below, and I will ask my trust-worthy attorney, Christian, for more information!

Make sure you sign up for my free weekly newsletter for divorce coaching and more!

More divorce coach advice from YourTango:

Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Lindsey Ellison

Divorce Coach

Lindsey Ellison

The Inspired Divorce

Email me today for a free 60-minute consultation!

Location: Annapolis, MD
Credentials: BA, BS
Other Articles/News by Lindsey Ellison:

When Saying 'I Love You' Isn't Good Enough


How many times has he told you he loved you, but then not acted in a way that reflects the true love he continues to profess? This often happens in two scenarios: You are in love with him and hoping for love in return, but he may not love you back. You're in a relationship but are falling out of love with him. Because he "loves" you, ... Read more

Why You Won't Get Closure From A Narcissist


There is something deeply ingrained in all of us that requires us to have closure. We need it when we leave our job, experience a death, if we fight with our best friend, and especially if we loved someone and the relationship ended. Closure may be a healthy conversation as to why we acted the way we did, or it can provide us answers about the reasons for the ... Read more

Men, Are You Willing To Give Up Your Marriage For Success?


As a women's divorce coach, the top complaints I hear from women who are considering divorce are: "He is never home because he is always working. And when he is home, he never pays attention to me." "He has it so easy. I take care of everything while he is away working. Why would he divorce me when I do everything for ... Read more

See More


Sign up for our daily email and get the stories everyone is talking about.

Ask The Experts

Have a dating or relationship question?
Visit Ask YourTango and let our experts and community answer.