'Part I: Starting a Dialogue With Your Partner
Perhaps no word in relationships, including those between gay men, is as inflammatory as "cheating"– the slang to denote one person in a relationship having sex with someone outside of that relationship in a way that too often results in feelings of anger, betrayal, and disappointment in the remaining partner. Yet some would say this dynamic simply borrows from an antiquated Legendary psychotherapist Michael Shernoff, LCSW, who has been an author, professor, and therapist specializing in gay men's issues in New York City for over 30 years, Unknown Objectwrote about "Negotiated Nonmonogamy and Male Couples" in a recent article for the academic journal, Family Process (Vol. 45, No. 4, 2006, pp. 407-418).
Shernoff offers a possible explanation for nonmonogamy in gay male couples in that it is related to gender. He contends that men tend to be more oriented than women toward a recreational approach to sex. He cites researcher Michael Bettinger, who suggests that this trait may be genetically hard-wired in men because it is evident in all human cultures throughout history. Additionally, he cites author Dominic Davies who suggests men may be more able to separate in their minds love from sex, and that gay men (who already defy heterosexist notions just by coming out) develop their own values system, refusing the "patriarchal and capitalist notion of a partner as a possession."
Shernoff categorizes gay male couples in four subtypes: 1) the sexually exclusive couple (monogamous); 2) the sexually non-exclusive but unacknowledged couple ("cheating"); 3) the primarily sexually exclusive couple, also known as "modified monogamy" (those that perhaps participate in occasional three-ways or group sex together); 4) the sexually non-exclusive acknowledged couple (the open relationship), and 5) non-sexual domestic partners. He describes how for some gay male couples, "fidelity" is defined by the emotional primacy of the relationship, and abiding by whatever rules the couple has agreed upon for how sex outside the relationship should manifest; while "infidelity" means not sex outside the relationship, but breaking the set rules, such as engaging in unprotected sex outside the relationship when it was agreed condoms would be used, or having sex locally when it was agreed they would play with others only while traveling.
Very often in my psychotherapy practice, my gay male clients discuss various concerns about getting their sexual needs met, including the gay couples I see. These couples describe how while their emotional commitments to each other are solid, some long for fulfilling a sexual need that lies outside the desires or even capabilities of their primary partner. This tension brings the couple to conjoint counseling to explore the issues and identify some options to resolve their dilemma. Others are in counseling because the relationship has been harmed by one or both partners "cheating" on the agreed-upon monogamous arrangement, and they seek help to understand why outside sex was desired. Sometimes this can be about power dynamics or unresolved emotional conflicts between the partners, while other times, perhaps more commonly, it is only about a natural male desire for sexual variety after the initial excitement that characterizes early relationships predictably wanes.
In Part II of this article (next issue), we will explore how couples further the dialogue and identify practical options.
More gay sex on YourTango: