The Number One Reason Guys Don't Call Back


The Number One Reason Guys Don't Call Back
Is your bossiness turning guys off? It's a date, not a job interview!

Jasbina asks Rachel Greenwald, "In your book Have Him At Hello: Confessions From 1,000 GUYS About What Makes Them Fall In Love...Or Never Call Back, you characterize the 'Boss Lady' as the #1 reason men don't call back. Tell us about that.

Rachel Greenwald: "I'll tell you all about the boss lady. It's important to set the context about how this research was conducted. I spent 10 years doing exit interviews on 1,000 guys. These are the former dates of clients of mine who I worked with as a matchmaker. They didn't call my clients back. I tracked them down—my clients gave me their phone numbers, and I called to find out what happened.


I didn't accept any bogus or vague reasons like:

  • 'There wasn’t any chemistry.'
  • 'I was just busy.'

I really wanted to get specific details.

In these conversations, the number one reason given was that the woman was a 'boss lady,' described as a woman who was a little more aggressive, argumentative and masculine.

The man concluded that she was terrific, but he'd like to hire her instead of date her.

This is funny because a lot of the women will hear that and say, 'He was just intimidated by me.'

  • In fact, the men were very clearly saying that they were not intimidated.
  • I probed that question a lot because I really suspected that was the case as well.
  • They were saying that they were not sexually or romantically attracted to a woman who was the boss lady and reminded him of someone that he worked with.

That was the gist of the number one reason. It played out in various subtle ways.

  • Some women were argumentative in their dates' minds.
  • In their own minds, they thought they were just sparring or bantering with their dates.

There was a story one guy told me that I think really summarizes this concept well.

A guy and a girl were on a date. The menu was in front of them. Their conversation:

  1. He said, 'Let's share an appetizer. Why don't you pick anything you like, except for curry? I don't eat curry.'
  2. She said, 'What? You don't eat curry? Why don't you eat curry?' She went on for a couple of minutes arguing with him about the curry and asking all sorts of questions.
  3. She thought she was just playing around or bantering. She asked, 'Are you allergic to it? Did you parents not try to introduce you to new foods when you were younger?'

He said that it became exhausting. He thought, 'She's just a difficult person.'

It would have been so nice for her to say, 'Okay, you don't want the curry? Let's order the artichoke dip.'

He thought:

  • 'This is really symbolic of the kind of person that I am not looking to marry.
  • I have a very challenging work life. I'm arguing and being challenged by people all day.
  • When I come home, I want to feel like someone's on my side. Certainly, I want someone intelligent. I want someone to be a great conversationalist.'

There is a difference between being argumentative and being a good conversationalist.

That was a really interesting description that symbolizes this whole category of women who are more the boss lady than a partner."

Jasbina Ahluwalia: "That's the number one reason that you came across?"

Rachel Greenwald: "That's right. A lot of this category also had to do with femininity.

  • It wasn't just about the verbal sparring.
  • It was also about the way that women looked.
  • If women looked more like someone professional that he would encounter at the office then he was less attracted to her.

In the research, I found out from these men as they were confessing the real reasons why they didn't call back, they said:

  • That women should look more like a girl.
  • No blazers, pants or short power haircuts.
  • They were more attracted to women with longer hair who wore skirts, high heels and dressed in a shapely way, not in boxy jackets.

It's not slutty. That would not symbolize a woman they were interested in marrying. It would be someone who had some flirtatious clothing on."

The above is an excerpt from Jasbina’s interview with Rachel Greenwald.

The entire interview transcript is at Rachel Greenwald Interview: Have Him At Hello! Listen to the entire interview on: Intersections Match Talk Radio—'Jasbina's Lifestyle Show', Blog Talk Radio: 'Have Him At Hello! Rachel Greenwald Interview', or on iTunes.

Jasbina Ahluwalia is an Indian American Attorney-turned-Entrepreneur, Relationship Expert, Radio Show Host and Matchmaker/Dating Coach. She is the Founder & President of Intersections Match by Jasbina, the only Premier Full-Service Selective Search, Dating / Relationship Coaching & Online Dating Support Firm—For Indian Singles. Jasbina is also the host of Intersections Talk Radio, a monthly holistic lifestyle show—conversations with published authors/experts on relationships and health and wellness. She has received worldwide press (Oprah, Chicago Tribune, Inc., Entrepreneur Magazine) including TV and Video & Radio.

For more information, please visit Feel free to submit a Question to be considered for this column to Jasbina directly at

For more from Jasbina:

This article was originally published at Reprinted with permission.

More Dating Rules advice on YourTango:

Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Jasbina Ahluwalia

Relationship Coach

Jasbina Ahluwalia
Founder & President

Intersections Match by Jasbina
Join our Radio Show
Add me on facebook 
Add me on LinkedIn
Follow us on Twitter

To be Considered as a Potential Match for Jasbina's Selective Clients: Create Free Account here.

Relationship Q&A Videos:  Jasbina has numerous Relationship Q&A Videos.

More from Jasbina - Read Her Blog

Listen in every 3rd Monday at 6:00 PM Eastern as Jasbina Ahluwalia Founder of Intersections Match Hosts a monthly show featuring Experts on trending topics on NetIP.

Location: San Francisco - Bay Area, CA
Credentials: JD, MA
Other Articles/News by Jasbina Ahluwalia:

7 Sad-But-True Signs Your Girlfriend Is Cheating on You


Trust is one of the most important aspects of a relationship and being confident that your girlfriend is being faithful is crucial to the success of your growing relationship. Here are seven signs that your girlfriend is either currently cheating on you or thinking about it: 1. She seems more interested in her phone than in you. It is true that ... Read more

Women are Pickier Than Men When Choosing a Partner


I will second that.  Given your extensive research as well as any personal experience, I’d like to give you the opportunity to share with our listeners, many of whom are singles who are very interested in finding their mates, any suggestions you may have for them. This would be based on your extensive research, personal experiences and the ... Read more

First Date Flubs: Forgive The Quirks


Jasbina Ahluwalia asks Lori Gottlieb – Author of the book Marry Him: The Case for Settling for Mr. Good Enough: What were some of the 300 things, in terms of character traits, that women were picky about? Lori Gottlieb They were so nit-picky. First Date Flubs: Celeb Impressions There were things like, “I thought he was really cute, ... Read more

See More

My Videos
Must-see Videos
Most Popular