Forbidden Love & Relationship Struggles On Downton Abbey


Relationships & Love On Downton Abbey
Love is in the air at the Abbey … but not everyone is singing the same tune! Photo: imdb
Can you relate to provocative Rose or steadfast Anna?

As Valentine's Day approaches, love is in the air in all shapes and forms at Downton Abbey. And when it comes to matters of the heart, last night's episode reminds us that whether it is 1922 or 2014, certain truths about love are timeless.

Never Know You Love Him Till You Let Him Go:
Downstairs, Ivy's love story is as old as time. For months she has overlooked Alfred's romantic gazes and gentlemanly gestures, while pining for the suave and stuck-up Jimmy. Even when Jimmy took her out and encouraged her to get so drunk she could barely walk, she continued to chose him over Alfred. Suddenly, Alfred has a chance to move up in the world through training in London at The Ritz. It is not until Alfred says goodbye that Ivy realizes her mistake and all she has lost. (Related: As a minority of the population watched this heartbreak play out at Downton, the modern day majority enjoyed the Superbowl and a hilarious commercial mocking this common dating dynamic!)  

More from YourTango: Rejection & Moving On: Lessons From Downton Abbey [Spoilers!]

Forbidden Love Can Make The Heart Grow Stronger:
Cousin Rose is bursting with excitement about a surprise concert she is planning for Lord Grantham's birthday celebration. It turns out that her enthusiasm is as much for the eloquent and elegant musician, Jack Ross, as it is for the music itself. While Rose does a wonderful job of helping Downton's upstairs and downstairs characters open their minds, her efforts seem somewhat contrived and immature. Mary catches Rose kissing Jack (Downton's first African American character) in the basement as viewers brace themselves for what is shaking up to be a classic tale of forbidden love. Given the various forums in which the provocative Rose has been pushing the envelope since she arrived at Downton, it seems possible that her passionate feelings for Jack are intensified by the taboos associated with their unfolding love story.  

When Times Are Tough, Commitment Is Essential:
Anna and Mr. Bates are doing what they can to get through Anna's unspeakable tragedy. Like many who are traumatized by rape, both she and Mr. Bates express a wish to forget about it and enjoy each other. Unfortunately, no matter how much they may both want to develop amnesia and forget all about it, the pain is too great and the trauma too deep. What is striking about their relationship during this episode is their willingness to talk openly about a topic that is tough to discuss in modern times and seemed unspeakable in the days of Downton:

Anna: "I know it can't be the same as it used to be. I don't deceive myself about that. But I want to make some new memories. Some good memories.  So it's not as if all our happiness was before."
Mr. Bates: "I'm happy whenever I look at you."
Anna: "But you're not, are you? Everything is shadowed. Every moment we share is shadowed."
Mr. Bates: "You're right.  Let's have one evening when we don't think about it. We [will] leave it all behind."

Following the awful phase of the prior episodes in which Anna shut Mr. Bates out of her life, they seem to have figured out that the only way through their pain is together. Life throws all kinds of unexpected curve balls, and when times are tough in a marriage, commitment matters as much as love. Anna and Mr. Bates' dignified and deliberate efforts are both heartbreaking and inspirational.

Better To Have Loved And Lost:
Lady Mary, Tom Branson and Lady Isobel gather in the nursery to spend some time with the children. Their conversation recalling their deceased beloveds is a beautiful testament to Tennyson's assertion that it is better to have loved and lost than to have never loved at all:

Lady Isobel: "When I got engaged, I was so In love with Reginald, I felt sick.  I was sick with love, literally.  It seems so odd to think about it now it really does."
Tom: "It was the same for me.  As if I'd gone mad or been hypnotized or something.  For days, weeks.  All I could think about was her."
Lady Mary: "And me.  I was standing outside in the snow, and I didn't have a coat.  But I wasn't cold, because all I kept thinking was, he's going to propose.  He's going to propose!"
Lady Isobel:  "Well, aren't we the lucky ones."

More from YourTango: Call in the Auntie Brigade! Lessons from Downton Abbey

More on relationships from YourTango:

Share this with someone you love (or even like a lot)!

Let's make it
FB official
Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Elisabeth LaMotte


Social worker, psychotherapist, blogger and author of "Overcoming Your Parents' Divorce"

Location: Washington, DC
Credentials: LICSW, MFT, MSW
Specialties: Communication Problems, Dating/Being Single Support, Divorce/Divorce Prevention
Other Articles/News by Elisabeth LaMotte:

How Much Porn is Too Much?


Internet porn has changed relationships and marriages in more ways than a couples therapist can count.  Questions on the pornography front are quite common.  Is it okay to watch together?  Is it okay to watch it alone?  If so, how much is too much?  These questions fall under the umbrella of decisions that individuals (and couples) must ... Read more

Lessons About Comfort From Lady Edith & Downton Abbey (SPOILERS)


Many people initiate therapy because they are aware that something needs to change. Unfortunately, change is not always easy or intuitive. Through years of work as a therapist, I have noticed that when someone is stuck, helping them to exit their comfort zone often serves as a catalyst for personal growth and transformation. It can be something as simple as ... Read more

Rejection & Moving On: Lessons From Downton Abbey [Spoilers!]


No relationship comes with a guarantee. In other words? Rejection is always a possibility. This week's episode of Downton Abbey highlights three painful rejection scenarios: Ivy rejects Alfred, Alfred rejects Daisy, and Mary rejects Lord Gillingham (yet again). While their relationships all deal with different dynamics and motivations, there's a real ... Read more

See More

Recent Expert Posts

Put Your Relationship on a Diet Free of Blame and Criticism

Replace the blame and criticism in your relationship with heartfelt gratitude and appreciations.


Why You'll Never Meet The Right Partner

Give up the search - and figure out how to actually create love instead.

Trouble In Paradise

The Honeymoon Is Over

Making marriage work post honeymoon phase

Ask The Experts

Have a dating or relationship question?
Visit Ask YourTango and let our experts and community answer.

How to find the right pro for you
10 Reasons Mental Health Pros Should Join YourTango Experts

10 Reasons Mental Health Pros Should Join YourTango Experts

YourTango Experts can help your business go from good to great.

10 Steps To Improve Your Coaching Business

Take your coaching business from mediocre to great in no time…

Frequently Asked Questions About YourTango Experts

Thinking of joining? Here's all the facts you need to know to make the most of your membership.

Getting Your Guy To Join You In A Therapy Or Coaching Session

So how can your get your strong, self-reliant, superman to talk to an Expert with you?

Therapist/Counselors: Who We Are & What We Do

What exactly does a therapist/counselor do and can they really help?

See more resources>