"I'm Open, You're Closed"

By

closed sign
Are you in a relationship where you believe that you are open and your partner is closed?

Rianna and Joel consulted with me because they kept getting stuck in their relationship whenever there was a conflict. It wasn't the issue itself that kept creating a problem, but how they were dealing with the issue.

Married for 7 years with three children, they loved each other deeply, and were both distressed when they were disconnected due to their inability to work through conflict.

"Rianna," I said in our conjoint phone session, "I'd like to hear about the issue from your point of view."

"Whenever we have a difference of opinion about something, I experience Joel getting angry and shutting down. I know I must be doing something to contribute to our communication problems, but I don't know what I'm doing. I think I'm open and caring and then I feel just awful when he closes and shuts down.

"So you think you are open and he is closed?"

"Yes, that is my experience."

"Joel, how do you see it?"

"I don't experience Rianna open at all. It feels like she is trying to control me and just have things her way. She doesn't listen to me or hear me."

"Honey," said Rianna, "I love you so much and I just want what is best for you and for us. I feel so sad when you think I'm trying to control you."

This was the dynamic that was a problem - happening right here in the moment. Having worked with couples for so many years, I'm very tuned in to intent, and it was clear to me that Rianna's intent in that moment was to talk Joel out of his feelings. Her intent to control was masked behind her soft voice.

"Joel, how are you feeling right now?"

"Frustrated. Pulled at. Manipulated. I want to shut down. She is not hearing me, not listening to me, but she is ACTING open."

"Rianna, you said you wanted to know your end of the system between you and Joel. You said you thought you were open in these conflicts, but right now you are not open. Even though your voice is soft and you are telling Joel you love him, you are explaining and defending instead of trying to understand what he is saying to you. This makes him feel pulled on and controlled. See if you can move into your heart, with curiosity about why Joel feels pulled at and controlled by you right now."

Rianna was silent for a moment. Then, from a truly open place, she said, "I just got it. I've been using my soft voice and caring words to convince him, but I haven't been trying to really understand his point of view about things. Wow, I never saw this before! I think I've been doing this our whole marriage!"

"Joel, how are you feeling right now?"

"Relief!"

"Joel, see if you can tune into what you feel inside when Rianna doesn't hear you and tries to talk you out of your feelings."

"I feel…I don’t know what the word is. Sad."

This article was originally published at . Reprinted with permission.
Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Dr. Margaret Paul

Author

Margaret Paul, Ph.D. is a best-selling author of 8 books, relationship expert, and co-creator of the powerful Inner Bonding® process - featured on Oprah, and recommended by actress Lindsay Wagner and singer Alanis Morissette. Are you are ready to heal your pain and discover your joy? Take our FREE Inner Bonding course, and click here for a FREE CD/DVD relationship offer. Visit our website at innerbonding.com for more articles and help, as well as our Facebook Page. Phone and Skype sessions available. Join the thousands we have already helped and visit us now!

Location: Pacific Palisades, CA
Credentials: PhD
Specialties: Anxiety Issues, Couples/Marital Issues, Depression
Other Articles/News by Dr. Margaret Paul:

Are You Addicted To Love?

By

Have you ever felt confused about whether your feelings in a relationship were coming from a healthy place or from a wounded place? This is Mari's concern: "How would you describe the difference between obsession/addiction and devotion? When you are deeply in love and moved to be emotionally and physically intimate with someone, how can you tell ... Read more

How Do YOU Feel About That? Avoiding Projection In Relationships

By

"I think I'm an open person, but Sarah keeps telling me how closed I am. She gets furious when she wants to talk about our relationship and I don't." Matthew, in his late 20s and married to Sarah for 2 years, had consulted me due to relationship problems and was feeling a lot of confusion about their relationship system. "There ... Read more

Get Over Fights Like A Grown-Up

By

Most couples fight at times. Unless they fight unfairly—hitting below the belt and saying very hurtful things or becoming physically abusive—this is generally not a problem. Couples who engage in verbal or physical abuse need to either get help on both an individual and relationship level or leave the relationship. Ongoing verbal and physical ... Read more

See More

Ask The Experts

Have a dating or relationship question?
Visit Ask YourTango and let our experts and community answer.