Alanon and powerlessness

By

Alanon and powerlessness
A central pillar of Alanon is the belief that you are powerless, in Bottled up we don't believe that


Also if you are told that something cannot be done then, most times, we don’t try to do it. So if we are told that we need to wait till the drinker is ready change because we cannot do anything about it, then most likely we will not try and change them. Yes we know that you have been trying to get him to change for years without any success, so being told that you are powerless both makes sense and is a relief since you don’t have to keep wasting your time trying. However after finding out you are powerless people tend to stop trying.

 

 

Motivation is the key to change


Not that long ago most rehabs were 12 step based. That meant that they (the therapists and doctors) also believed that people were powerless over alcohol and we had to wait until the drinker was ready to change. One eminent researcher was asked “What makes a good therapist?”. His answer was “One that is there when the drinker wants to change.


In the early 1980s research showed that, rather than just wait, if instead you address people’s motivation they change (you would expect that wouldn’t you, you expect that treatment would change drinkers). This was not a new revelation, the ancient Greeks knew it and so did you. Most people react to people doing things that they don’t like by making their feelings plain, they shout, nag, punish etc. Sometimes this works. Indeed at one time it was the accepted way of teaching children and criminals right from wrong. Other times it tends to make a bad situation even worse and living with a drinker seems to be one of those situations. However, there are ways we can address the drinker’s motivation that don’t involve these methods and they are much more effective.


We are not saying it's easy, it's not in fact it feels very counter-intuitive but if you change your reactions and so change the context for the drinker this in turn may result in them changing their behaviour. It does not work for everybody but it can work more often than not. Research has shown that when people used these methods around two thirds of their drinkers sought treatment compared with about one third for people who were in Alanon. In fairness to Alanon they never suggest that you can influence your drinker. After all they suggest that you are powerless. We don’t believe that you are.

Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Dr John McMahon & Lou Lewis

Author

Dr John McMahon & Lou Lewis

Bottled Up

john@247helpyourself.com

Location: Exeter, DEV, United Kingdom
Credentials: BS, PhD
Specialties: Addiction, Drug and Alcohol, Family Support
Website: Bottled Up
Other Articles/News by Dr John McMahon & Lou Lewis:

Is My Partner An Alcoholic?

By

Living with an alcoholic means living with doubt and uncertainty. There is the obvious uncertainty: will he be late or even turn up at all? Will she get through the evening without making a fool of herself and upsetting our friends? Anyone reading this that lives with an alcoholic will instantly recognise that feeling of insecurity, where the only thing that ... Read more

Why Do Alcoholics Refuse To Stop Drinking?

By

It seems crazy, booze is making him ill, everyone can see that, her friends don't want to be around her, and she can't see that. Why can't they see what everyone else sees so clearly? Why do they seem incapable of recognizing that that there is a problem at all and that it is destroying them?  With all these signs of a problem, why do ... Read more

From Philip Seymour Hoffman To Shawn Pyfrom: Life As An Addict

By

Philip Seymour Hoffman dies of a Heroin overdose and Shawn Pyfrom publicly admits to being an alcoholic and a drug addict on the same day. What a powerful message that addiction is no respecter of gender, age or social status. It can affect people who seem to have everything just as easily as those with nothing. We have no intention of moralising in this ... Read more

See More

 
PARTNER POSTS
Latest Expert Videos
ASK YOURTANGO MORE QUESTIONS
Must-see Videos
SEE MORE VIDEOS
Most Popular