The Twosome Delusion


The Twosome Delusion
Monogamy's a fiction. Why? Because we're not unitary. We've all got multiple personality disorder.

I'll start with a radical statement: we are delusional, each and every one of us.

Culturally delusional, too.

How so? Because we have this notion of a single, unitary self when that's not actually what we are. This has profound and subtle effects on how we are, and who we are, in our intimate relationships.

The cards are stacked in favor of our making this mistake. We've got one body, which implies one self, and on top of that our language uses the first person singular, not plural, to describe us. I'm "I" or "me," not "us" and "we."

The body lies. Our language lies. We have multiple selves crowding inside our one body and one "I." It's like a 19th Century tenement there inside us. 

I'll use myself as an example. I have a confident self that can do no wrong, an uncertain self that's constantly worrying about screwing up, an outgoing self who has a great time hanging out with other people, a brooding self who views social encounters as fundamentally unnourishing, a do-gooder self who cares deeply about the state of the world, a selfish self who cares first and foremost about The Moi, and--well, I could go on and on.

I'm not alone in this. We’ve all got multiple personality disorder, except it's not a disorder, it's part of the natural order.

Psychologists describe people as "conflicted." Not exactly: I’m not one person divided, I’m two (or more people) disagreeing.

Apply the multiple personality model of the self to intimate relationship and it can get strangely liberating.

First, it suggests monogamy is a fiction. Think you're in a relationship with just one person? Think again. One of my -exes and I used to have subpersonality dates. Boy, did I have fun with her dive-bar self! I wasn't cheating, but it was as if I were going out with a different person. It offered the rush of the new and was a great change of pace.

Second, communication can get fundamentally more honest, assuming we have the courage to go where the multiple personality model takes us.

In Unitary-Self Land, “I” am supposed to love my partner through and through, in every fiber of my being. I’m supposed to feel this way even in the face of contrary evidence, like when that thing he does makes me totally nuts, or those phases I go through when I wish he’d take a really long vacation to, say, Antarctica. And maybe fall in love with a penguin.

The multiple personality model helps us make sense of these contradictions. Many of me loves my partner, some of me is annoyed by her, and a couple of characters in there wish she would !@#$%^&* go away!

The multiple personality model not only opens our internal landscape in this way, it tells us something important about these feelings (or, more exactly, selves)—specifically, that there’s nothing wrong with them. We don’t have to feel guilty when we're not feeling in love with, or particularly loving of, our partner. It’s inevitable and nothing to fret about—part of the multiple-personality natural order of things.

This article was originally published at . Reprinted with permission.
Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Carl Frankel


Carl Frankel is a writer specializing in sex and relationships. He is also a relationship coach and the managing director of Sheri Winston's Center for the Intimate Arts.

He is the author of Love and the More Perfect Union: Six Keys to Relationship Bliss. He is also a listed author on the forthcoming Succulent Sexcraft: Your Hands-On Guide to Erotic Play and Practice, by Sheri Winston with Carl Frankel. This is the highly-awaited sequel to Sheri's Women's Anatomy of Arousal: Secrets Maps to Buried Pleasure, which won the 2010 AASECT Book of the Year Award (American Association of Sex Educators, Counselors and Therapists).

Do you want $800 in great gifts (as in, FREE gifts) from wonderful sex and relationship teachers? It's easy! Click here for more info. But you'll have to check this out by September 16th to qualify!


Location: Kingston, NY
Credentials: Other
Other Articles/News by Carl Frankel:

Understanding Your Inner Music Is The Key To Relationships


Relationships are challenging. Hell, even good relationships are challenging. It's one of those semi-unfathomable mysteries — why is love so hard? There's actually an answer to this question. Love is hard because it's what the script calls for. Say what? What script? Great question. My answer will take you through the wee ... Read more

Why Believing In Soul Mates Is Keeping You Single & Unhappy


So you think you've finally found that perfect person you've been waiting for? You fit together so well and in so many ways. He or she is your soul mate. It's an ancient dream, this longing to end the abyss that separates one person from another. Over two thousand years ago, Plato proposed that man and woman were once one. They were split ... Read more

The Three Most Important Words in a Relationship


Back in the 1970s—and I know I’m dating myself—a Yale law professor named Erich Segal penned a bestselling tearjerker called Love Story. His definition of love: “Love means never having to say you’re sorry.” Straight out of the Woodstock era and ethos, it sounded good at the time. Freedom! No guilt! Just be yourself! ... Read more

See More

Ask The Experts

Have a dating or relationship question?
Visit Ask YourTango and let our experts and community answer.