How Can You End a Marriage That Never Was


How Can You End a Marriage That Never Was
Many divorcing couples are under the illusion they had a real marriage. I propose this is false.

When looking at divorce, we tend to make several assumptions. We assume that the relationship in question didn’t work out for various reasons. Frequently, we see one more at fault that the other. In addition, we may all agree that the relationship needs to be dissolved as quickly as possible and the two partners need to move on to a new life.

Yet, what if I were to tell you that all these assumptions are based on a false premise that there was a marriage to end in the first place? What if there was only a marriage in name only? Then the question changes from asking, “How are we going to end this marriage?” to “What are we really ending?” In fact, have these two people even been in a marriage that requires an end?


I believe that many marriages, especially those which end in divorce, are merely arenas designed for the sole purpose of allowing each partner to achieve their individual needs: money, security, sex, children, or safety. In my view, this purpose does not speak to the essence of what a marriage is. As Carl Whitaker, a famous family therapist says, “Without an ‘Us-ness,’ there is no marriage.” A relationship requires a WE or an US. A relationship is not two people competing over their needs or even meeting another’s needs for a period of time.

The WE part is considered an entity in and of itself that transcends the self-serving needs, desires, and wants of the individual partners. It is much more than occupying space under the same roof or taking care of specific wants: sexual satisfaction, being provided for, or creating children in one’s image. Therapist and psychologist Terry Hargrave says, “A strong marriage requires both partners to let go of their single-minded search for self-fulfillment and commit themselves to the care and health of a third entity – the precious and fragile relationship they are creating together.” The relationship about which I am speaking has its own voice that is not his or hers, and which reflects the state of the WE that is present. Any time the voice of the relationship is not present, the marriage will be shaky or mostly a caricature. The tone of the WE voice is typically soft, its words brief, and it will never debate, defend, or attempt to prove what it says.

When I address the US of the struggling couples whom I work with, I hear the cries of the relationship: “I am emotionally starving,” “I feel sad,” “Proving that you are right doesn’t feed me,” “Slow down,” or “I need you to have a shared vision.” I have watched numerous couples, who would normally argue and polarize over anything and everything, merely listen when this voice is recognized as an entity separate from them.

This article was originally published at The Relationship Doctor Bruce Derman. Reprinted with permission.
Article contributed by
Advanced Member

Doctor Bruce Derman


Bruce Derman, Ph.D.

The great thing about my books is they provide you with a core understanding of relationship based on my 43 years of being a psychotherapist. They teach you how to move through your impasses without spending countless hours in therapy with the wrong therapist.                         

Location: Woodland Hills, CA
Credentials: PhD
Other Articles/News by Doctor Bruce Derman:

The Illusive Demands Of The Committed, Intimate Relationship


In looking over the YourTango website on love and relationships, the words commitment and intimacy are prominently featured over and over again, and many a love-seeker is caught up in this quest. This pattern is similar in my psychotherapy practice in which numerous clients come in asking for my help in finding a committed and intimate relationship. Those ... Read more

How To (Finally) Get Over Your Breakup And Move On


It's one of the most difficult situations we face in our life: letting go of an intimate relationship that has ended (for whatever reason). After all, we have invested a lot of energy into this person and we thought it was going to be a love that would last forever. We believe that the reason our partner gave us for ending the relationship—as we claim ... Read more

Sex Video: How Do I Get My Wife Interested In Sex Again?


Do you have to beg your spouse to have sex with you? Wondering how you can get your partner interested in sex again? If so, our instructional sex video can help. In this video, sex therapist and YourTango Expert Bruce Derman says that unfortunately, sexual disinterest is a common dynamic in couples. He suggests talking things out. "Maybe she ... Read more

See More

My Videos
Must-see Videos
Most Popular