Granted, the diamond in question was on her right hand, not left, according to People, and it may not even be a gift from Justin at all.
"It's the same ring she has worn forever on her right hand," a source tells the mag.
However, if Justin did pop the question in Paris, would the 43-year-old actress really be so blasé as to just casually start wearing the ring on her left ring finger? (We suspect if there was a wedding in the works, there would be an official announcement from her publicist, likely accompanied by fireworks.) 5 Love Lessons We Can Learn from Jennifer Aniston
Perhaps Jennifer is keeping her engagement news on the down-low, or maybe she just likes toying with the press. Either way, Jen looks good with some bling on her hand!
More juicy content from YourTango:
- How To End An Engagement
- 5 Weird And Notable Engagement Rings
- 9 Signs You Should Make Him Engagement Chicken
Photo Credit: Getty