So far, same-sex marriage is only legal in three states: Connecticut, Massachusetts and Iowa. Although it will be legal in Vermont on September 1, 2009, and in Maine on September 14, 2009, the rest of the country is sorely behind.
One argument being made by the opposition is that the purpose of marriage is to make babies. A man and a woman get married for the sake of starting a family and that alone is what defines "marriage." Read: How To Make A Baby (And Enjoy Trying)
While we prepare an endless rebuttal, let's just play along for a minute and for arguments sake.
Beyond any issues of infertility or illness, there are men and women who are married in the eyes of the state, enjoying all of the legal benefits, who have no intention of having children. They seek only companionship and all of the entitlements that come with marriage. Sex, joy, partnership, caring. All of that is theirs, even though they will never bear children and willfully so. If the state says they are free to do that, why aren't gay couples, as well.
More Juicy Content From YourTango: