I Deceived My Wife; Our Tax Return Didn't
He hid money from his wife, but his tax return spilled the beans.

Being a newly married couple involves adjusting to life as husband and wife, reminiscing about your nuptials, and sorting through what presents to keep and which to return—rarely does it involve preparing for the relationship to end. The sad reality, though, is that the lifespan of a marriage can be shorter than that of the loan taken out for a young couple's new house.
As the child of a divorced family, I got to see first-hand how lawyer bills stack up and how a woman's scorn can lead to a man sleeping in a car without money, food or change of clothes. With this memory in mind, I prepared myself for the unfortunate event that my wife and I would split. Little did I know that my earnest preparation would become fuel for the flame of an almost-divorce.
It all came out during tax season.
I had put money away slowly in a separate account just in case things didn't work out with my wife. By cashing a portion of my paychecks, I was able create small reserve and still keep some for myself for casual spending. (A few days a week at the driving range can add up pretty quick even if you're only hitting a bucket or two of balls.) Saving twenty dollars here and fifty dollars there, I quickly built up a nest egg that needed to be accounted for while filing my taxes.
My wife knew I kept a little cash in my wallet. There was no surprise there. It was when she looked over our tax return that she became suspicious. The amount of money I made and the amount I brought home didn't add up. When she approached me, I had no choice but to tell her the truth.
"While I may love you, the reality of divorce has forced me to prepare for the worst," I told her.
I might as well have slept with her sister; the trust in our relationship thinned like melting ice over a lake.
To her, it seemed like putting away a little cash meant that I wanted a divorce, that I was not happy with our marriage and that I was planning on leaving her with the money I had saved. I considered it more of a safety net than a nest egg. The explanation did not go over well. No matter how hard I tried, I could not convince her that I did not want to leave her.
We fought for days and went nights without talking before we realized that my doubt arose from my parents' divorce. I didn't believe that marriage could last, and I brought that uncertainty into my marriage. But it wasn't our fault that my parents got divorced, and it wasn't our fault that lawyers were so expensive. I closed the account, and stopped going to the driving range for a while.
I am happy to say that our marriage is strong once again. (It helped that I showered her with kisses and gifts from the extra cash I had in "our" account.) The sad part is that while I felt that I wasn't doing anything wrong, I was actually lying to my wife. Hiding money is the same as hiding the phone number of another woman. The truth always comes out, as they say, and it was tax season that revealed my folly.
Discussion
I understand having separate accounts and all, and that's completely fine if both of you go into knowing what it is. This man was HIDING it from his wife. It's a complete trust issue, and it can just lead to so many problems. Such as, it was so easy for him to hide money from her, what else is he or can he be hiding? Even if he isn't hiding anything else, even if he never does anything like this again, the wife will ALWAYS be suspicious. So for him to say he "took care of things" is BS, maybe in his mind things are great, maybe for now they are, but wait until the moment she suspects even the tiniest bit of untruthfulness and this is all going to blow up in his face, again.
As an infidelity expert who has been researching infidelity for the past 15 years, I have found that financial infidelity and marital infidelity usually go hand in hand. Finding evidence of one kind of infidelity will usually alert an unsuspecting spouse to the existence of the other. A significant amount of financial infidelity is discovered during the tax season when couples file their joint income tax returns. Your 1040 Form, the attached schedules, and the financial documents used to prepare your taxes may contain numerous signs of financial or marital infidelity. But knowing what to look for is the key. There is a post on my blog that goes into more detail about the connection between financial infidelity and marital infidelity. You can find it here http://infidelityadvice.blogspot.com/2009/04/joint-tax-returns-can-revea... There’s also a free tip sheet on where to look and what to look for.
In these times, good for you for putting some money aside as a small security blanket. Your wife totally overreacted and acted as if she had never thought of something like that on her own. Which if she didn't, is a problem. Every woman should have in the back of their mind that the relationship might not work out, you never know what's gonna happen. Sounds like she knew her pouting would get her a few new nice things...
First of all I want to know what fabulous gifts you bought for your wife that allowed her to forgive you. I don't think she only let him off the hook because of presents, I'm sure that was just icing on the cake. However, this issue isn't just a matter of someone lying and that means he's wrong. Divorce is a big issue, and I'm glad it sounds like you two were able to patch everything up!
Oh my god! I can't believe you treated your wife like this. I know you didn't do it on purpose (you were clearly only doing it because you were so caught up in your own issues) but it was still awful. You're so lucky she found it in her heart to forgive you in the end.
There's nothing wrong with separate accounts. My wife and I each have our own and a shared household one. Personally, I think it's a good idea. And even those financial planning people my wife loves to watch on TV say the same thing.
But in this case, it's clearly not about the bank accounts. It's about the fact that you've got some serious mommy and daddy issues that you threw your wife into the middle of them.
I hope she still has a separate account for her sake.
This is frightening. I totally looked over our tax return this year and when my husband saw me looking at it he was overjoyed that I was taking an interest in taxes and started talking to me about withholdings and our investments. Ugh. I guess that means I'm safe?

